Tuesday, 21 April 2015

OUDG404- What is a book? final crit

Final crit comments

Positive comments

  •       Clear layout
  •       Easy to follow
  •        Clear diagram
  •       Good colour scheme
  •        Good Production binding
  •        Minimal
  •        Legible


I was really happy to see these comment as it most of the things I was happy about my own book and also the parts I worked hard on, like the layout, easy to follow and the legibility, and also the binding method. So I was happy to see them comments.

Negative comment

  •       Needs glossary
  •       Contact page
  •       Proof read
  •       Not sure on glossy cover
  •       Water proof stock
  •       Water proof sleeve


I was happy to see these comments as well they were many things I have thought of my self and would change if I made this book again.

Needs glossary

Defiantly could do with a glossary to help beginners in fishing to understand the terminology, however I think most people in fishing would understand it.

Proof read

I did proof read my work and checked it all but however I must of miss spell to words and did notice it.

Glossy cover

I chose to do the glossy cover as it flexible and you could take to the lake and put it in your fishing bag and if it got a bit dirty you could clean it, however I do understand that it probably doesn’t go with the context of the book, maybe a textured paper would have been better.

Waterproof

Waterproof stock was defiantly an idea I thought of doing and if I did have a big budget of this book I would defiantly print it of on waterproof stock.

Sleeve

A sleeve was another idea I thought of doing but because of time I didn’t do it. I always like Sagmeister book with the cover and think I would of looked really good in a sleeve and would also protected it when down the lake on in your pocket or fishing bag.

The comment my peers made really have helped me and if I had another week I would defiantly apply these to it.  




No comments:

Post a Comment